Template:Short description Template:Use dmy dates Template:Infobox criminal organization
Thuggee (Template:IPAc-en, Template:IPAc-en) was a network of organized crime in British Raj India in the 19th century of gangs that traversed the Indian subcontinent murdering and robbing people.<ref name="thugs">"Tracing India's cult of Thugs". 3 August 2003. Los Angeles Times.</ref> A member of Thugee was referred to as a Thug.
The Thugs were purported to have murdered their victims by strangling using a bandana as a tool.<ref name="David Scott Katsan 2006 141" /> The Thugs were believed to practice their killings as a form of worship toward the goddess Kali.<ref name="Will Sweetman, Aditya Malik" /> For centuries, the authorities of the Indian subcontinent, such as the Khalji dynasty,<ref name="Martine van Woerkens 2002 110" /> the Mughal Empire,Template:Sfn and the British Raj, attempted to curtail the criminal activities of Thuggee during their rule.Template:Sfn
Contemporary scholarship is increasingly sceptical of the thuggee concept, and has questioned the existence of such a phenomenon,<ref name="Cambridge Scholars Publishing">Template:Cite book</ref><ref name="ReferenceA"/> which has led many historians to describe thuggee as the invention of the British colonial regime.<ref name="S. Shankar 2001">Template:Cite book</ref>
EtymologyEdit
ठग (Template:IAST), translated from Hindi as "swindler" or "deceiver". It is related with the verb thugna ("to deceive"), from the Sanskrit स्थग (Template:IAST 'cunning, sly, fraudulent') and स्थगति (Template:IAST, 'he conceals').<ref>{{#invoke:citation/CS1|citation |CitationClass=web }}</ref> This term, describing the murder and robbery of travellers, was popular in the northern parts of the Indian subcontinent, especially the northern and eastern regions of India.<ref name="thugs"/> The English word thug is derived from the same roots as the term "Thuggee".<ref>Template:Cite book</ref>
The Thuggee reportedly operated as gangs of highwaymen who tricked and murdered their victims by strangling. To take advantage of their victims, the thugs would join travellers and gain their confidence, which would allow them to surprise and strangle the travellers with a handkerchief or noose.<ref name="David Scott Katsan 2006 141">Template:Cite book</ref> One of the Thuggee would befriend their potential targets (even to the point of assuming their religion) and accompany them for a while to assess their potential wealth.<ref name="Mike Dash 193">Template:Cite book</ref><ref name="Mike Dash; Thuggee" /> Eventually, as one Thug managed to distract their victims by engaging them in conversation, the other members who were tasked with the killing would strangle them swiftly from behind.<ref name="Thug; True story of india" /> After the murder, they sometimes mutilated the corpses to hide evidence,<ref name="Mike Dash 73">Template:Cite book</ref> and buried the remains.<ref>Template:Cite book</ref>Template:Sfn Their modus operandi led to the thugs being called Phansigar ("using a noose"), a term more commonly used in southern India.<ref name="RussellLai1995">Template:Cite book</ref>
Although strangulation is one of their most-recognised methods of murder, they also used blades and poison.Template:Sfn The Thuggee gangs usually commenced their act in the evening,<ref name="Thug; True story of india" /> and attacked travelling groups whose numbers were smaller than their own groups to avoid unnecessary losses.<ref name="Mike Dash; Thuggee" /> To avoid suspicion, they carried only a few swords.<ref name="Thug; True story of india">Template:Cite book</ref> The poisonous ingredients which prepared by the Thuggee were consisted of Datura metel, the Indian thornapple, (family Solanaceae), a poisonous plant sacred to Shiva<ref name= "Siklos VMT">Template:Cite journal</ref><ref name= "Geeta & Gharaibeh">Template:Cite journal</ref> with powerful deliriant properties, were sometimes used by thugs to induce drowsiness or stupefaction, making strangulation easier.<ref name="mikedash"/> The Hindi name for the plant धतूरा (dhatūra) is derived from the Sanskrit and was adapted by Linnaeus into the Latinate genus name Datura.<ref>Schultes, Richard Evans; Hofmann, Albert (1979). The Botany and Chemistry of Hallucinogens (2nd ed.) pub. Springfield Illinois: Charles C. Thomas. Pages 283 and 288</ref><ref name= "Symon & Haegi">'Datura (Solanaceae) is a New World Genus' by D.E. Symon and L. Haegi in (page 197 of) Solanaceae III: Taxonomy Chemistry Evolution, Editors J.G. Hawkes, R.N. Lester, M. Nee & N. Estrada, published by The Royal Botanic Gardens Kew, Richmond, Surrey, UK for The Linnean Society of London 1991. Template:ISBN.</ref>
A leader of a Thuggee was called jemadar.<ref>Template:Cite book</ref> This was derived from military-style ranks such as jemadar and subedar among Thugs as well as reference to individual members as a "private", suggests that the organisation of their gangs had a military link.Template:Sfn They used a jargon known as Ramasee to disguise their true intentions from their targets.<ref name="Mike Dash 73"/> The Thuggee members comprised some who had inherited Thuggee as a family vocation, and others who were forced to turn to it out of necessity.Template:Sfn The leadership of many of the groups tended to be hereditary with family members sometimes serving together in the same band. Such thugs were known as aseel.<ref>Template:Cite book</ref> According to a Thuggee testimony, a young initiate who joined the group was usually trained by a senior experienced Thuggee member who held the title of guru.<ref>Template:Cite book</ref> While they usually kept their acts a secret, female thugs also existed and were called baronee in Ramasee, while an important male Thuggee was called baroo.<ref>Template:Cite book</ref>
The Thuggee usually avoided killing the children of the victims and instead adopted them.Template:Sfn However, sometimes they resorted to killing women and children to eliminate witnesses.<ref>Template:Cite book</ref> Some of the thugs avoided murdering victims they considered proscribed according to their beliefs and let other unscrupulous members commit the murder or were forced to let them by those who did not believe in their customs like the Muslim thugs.<ref>Template:Cite book</ref> Many of them avoided committing the robberies near the areas in which they lived, to avoid recognition and criminal repercussion.<ref name="Mike Dash; Thuggee">Template:Cite book</ref>
HistoryEdit
OriginsEdit
There were numerous traditions about their origin:
- One theory stated the Thuggee existed back to 1760. Based on genealogies which were recounted by some thugs, historian Mike Dash stated that the origin of the Thuggee can be dated back to the second half of the 17th century. A general consensus among them was that they originated in Delhi. A Thuggee named Gholam Hossyn who was caught in early 1800s stated that his accomplices believed that thugs had existed since the time of Alexander the Great. Another tradition among Thugs who lived in the early 1800s stated that they had lived in Delhi till the time of Akbar and consisted of seven great Muslim clans, although they had Hindu names, during the period. After one of them killed a favoured slave of Akbar, they left Delhi for other regions to avoid being targeted by the emperor.<ref name="Mike Dash 28, 36 & 37"/>
- The earliest known reference to the Thugs as a band or fraternity, rather than ordinary thieves, is found in Ziau-d din Barni's History of Firoz Shah (written about 1356).<ref name="brit">{{#invoke:citation/CS1|citation
|CitationClass=web }}</ref> He narrated an incident of the sultan Jalal-ud-din Khalji having arrested 1,000 Thugs, and expelling them to the Lakhnauti.<ref name="Martine van Woerkens 2002 110">Template:Cite book</ref> At first, Jalal-ud-din took a lenient attitude towards the Thuggees as he thought he could make them obedient with a softer approach. However, this approach proved counter productive according to modern historian Syama Prasad Basu, and encouraged insolence towards the Sultan.<ref name="Rise and Fall of Khilji Imperialism; 33">Template:Cite book</ref>
- Donald Friell McLeod theorised the Thuggee members originated from some Muslim tribes formed from those who fled Delhi after murdering a physician. Another source traced it to some great Muslim families who fled after murdering a favored slave of Akbar.<ref name="Mike Dash 28, 36 & 37">Template:Cite book</ref> According to this view, the original Muslim Thugs spread Thuggee amongst Hindus.Template:Sfn
- Another tradition preserved by the Thuggee clan members stated that they were Kanjars or descended from those who worked in the Mughal camps.Template:Sfn <ref name="Martine van Woerkens 136">Template:Cite book</ref><ref name="Mike Dash 37">Template:Cite book</ref> A Thuggee member has testified that some of his predecessors were forced to disguise themselves as members of the Kanjar tribe after fleeing Delhi, although they were originally descended from certain high-caste Muslim tribes. The said Thuggee, however, stated that their claimed descent was unverified and that some of them may be partially descended from the lower castes who worked in the Mughal army's camps. However, Mike Dash stated that the Thuggee's claim of being closed to outsiders is contradicted by the fact that people of all backgrounds were allowed to join them by the early 19th century according to available evidence.<ref name="Mike Dash 37"/> A Brahmin Thuggee who was interrogated by British Raj counselor William Henry Sleeman referred to the Muslim Thuggees as Kanjar tribesmen. However, another member of Thuggee refuted this.<ref name="Martine van Woerkens 136"/>
- Donald Friell McLeod, Lieutenant Governor of Punjab Province, who led the campaign against them in the Rajputana Agency, recorded the traditions of their origins. According to them, they were originally Muslims and were taught Thuggee by the deity Devi or Bhavani. They then joined the Lodha people and migrated to Delhi, where 84 tribes—which were a part of all the criminal clans of India—also became a part of the Thugs. A physician who belonged to these 84 tribes gained prominence after curing a royal elephant and was murdered by other Thugs. A schism developed and they left Delhi, which in turn resulted in the existence of seven Muslim tribes. According to McLeod, these tribes were named Bhyns, Bursot, Kachinee, Hutar, Kathur Gugra, Behleem and Ganoo. According to him, the thugs from Delhi were separated into more than 12 "classes".Template:Sfn
16th century onwardsEdit
.jpg){kind=link}
In the 16th century Surdas, in his allegorical couplet, mentioned robbers called "thags" who would lure victims into their clutches to kill them and steal their property. Ibn Battuta, on his way to Calicut from Delhi as an envoy to China, was attacked by bandits, who probably were thugs.<ref>Template:Harvnb; Template:Harvnb</ref> The Janamsakhis used the term thag to refer to a robber who used to lure pilgrims. Jean de Thévenot in his 1665 account referred to a band of robbers who used a "certain Slip with a running noose" to strangle their victims. John Fryer also mentions a similar method of strangling used by robbers from Surat whom he saw being given capital punishment by the Mughals in 1675. He mentioned that three of them were relatives, which Kim A. Wagner notices is similar to the Thugs who were thought to have engaged in this as a family profession. A decree issued by Aurangzeb in 1672 refers to a similar method and uses the term "Phansigar".Template:Sfn
The garrote is often depicted as a weapon of the Thuggee.<ref name="Popplewell1995">Template:Cite book</ref><ref name="GreshWeinberg2008">Template:Cite book</ref> Other evidences suggest that the katar (dagger) was their personal status weapon, the Thuggee wore this weapon proudly across their chest. Early references to Thugs reported they committed their strangulation murders with nooses of rope or catgut, but later they adopted the use of a length of cloth that could be used as a sash or scarf, and thus more easily concealed.<ref name="mikedash">Dash, Mike Thug: the true story of India's murderous cult Template:ISBN, 2005</ref> This cloth is sometimes described as a rumāl (head covering or kerchief), translated as "yellow scarf"; "yellow", in this case, may refer to a natural cream or khaki colour rather than bright yellow.
The Thuggees preferred to use the method of strangulation in order to take advantage of loopholes in civil law which persisted from the times of the Mughal Empire, which ruled most of India from the 1500s.<ref name="mikedash"/> For a murderer to be sentenced to death, he or she must have shed the blood of their victim. Those who murdered but did not shed blood might face imprisonment, hard labor and paying a penalty—but they would not risk execution.Template:Citation needed
The "River Thugs" preyed upon people including Hindu pilgrims travelling using the Ganga river and became mostly active during the winter like their compatriots from Murnae, Bundelkhand and Awadh. Their dialect of Ramasee differed from the one used by their compatriots on land and used boats taken on lease from their builders or from a jemadar called Khuruck Baboo. Sleeman states that they tapped three times to give the signal to murder which they always committed during the day. To avoid detection of a corpse, they broke its back and threw it in the river to be eaten by crocodiles and only robbed money or jewels.<ref>Template:Cite book</ref>
British suppressionEdit
The British found out about them in Southern India for the first time in 1807, while in Northern India they were discovered in 1809 with an effort to suppress them being carried out from 1809 to 1812.Template:Sfn
After a dispute developed between the Zamindar official named Tejun with a Thuggee named Ghasee Ram in 1812, the latter took refuge with his family under another landlord called Laljee. Tejun in turn revealed the thugs of Sindouse to Nathaniel Halhed.Template:Sfn Thomas Perry, the magistrate of Etawah, assembled some soldiers of the East India Company under the command of Halheld in 1812 to suppress the Thugs.<ref>Template:Cite book</ref> Laljee and his forces including over 100 Thugs were defeated, with the village of Murnae, a headquarter of the Thugs, destroyed and burnt by the Company soldiers.<ref>Template:Cite book</ref> Laljee fled to Rampura and the southern banks of Sindh River but was caught by the Marathas who turned him over to the company.<ref>Template:Cite book</ref>Template:Sfn
British authorities had occasionally captured and prosecuted Thugs, circulating information about these cases in newsletters or the journal Asiatick Researches of The Asiatic Society. However, Sleeman seems to have been the first to realize that information obtained from one group of stranglers might be used to track and identify other thugs in a different district. His first major breakthrough was the capture of "Feringhea" (also known as Syeed Amir Ali, Khuda Buksh, Deahuct Undun and Daviga Persaud<ref name="David Scott Katsan 2006 141"/>), who was persuaded to turn King's evidence. (Feringhea's story was the basis of the successful 1839 novel Confessions of a Thug). Feringhea brought Sleeman to a mass grave with a hundred bodies, told him the circumstances of the murders and named the Thugs who had committed them.<ref name=Twain>Template:Cite book</ref>
After initial investigations confirmed what Feringhea had said, Sleeman began an extensive campaign using profiling and intelligence. Sleeman was made superintendent of the Thuggee and Dacoity Department in 1835, an organ of the Indian government first established by the East India Company in 1830.<ref>Template:Cite book</ref> (Dacoity referred to organised banditry, distinguished from thugs most notably by its open practice and due to the fact that murder was not an intrinsic element of their modus operandi.) Sleeman developed elaborate intelligence techniques that pre-dated similar methods in Europe and the US by decades.<ref name="mikedash" /> During the 1830s, the thugs were targeted for eradication by the Governor-General of India, Lord William Bentinck, and his chief captain, William Henry Sleeman.Template:Citation needed
Records were made in which the accused were given prisoner numbers, against which their names, residences, fellow thugs, and the criminal acts for which they were blamed were also noted. Many thugs' names were similar; they often lacked surnames since the Thuggee naming convention was to use the names of their tribes, castes and job assignments in the gangs. Accurate recording was also difficult because the thugs adopted many aliases, with both Muslim and Hindu thugs often posing as members of the other religion. By the testimony from a Thuggee named Ghulam Hussain, Hindu and Muslim Thuggees avoided eating together, such was not the case for drinking and smoking.<ref name="Mike Dash 193"/><ref name="David Scott Katsan 2006 141"/>
The campaign relied heavily on captured thugs who became informants. These informants were offered protection on the condition that they told everything that they knew. According to historian Mike Dash, who used documents in the UK archives, suspects were subject to bench trials before British judges. Though the trials were lacking by later standards (e.g., suspects were not allowed legal representation), they were conducted with care to protocols of the time. While most suspects were convicted, Dash notes that the courts genuinely seemed interested in finding the truth and rejected a minority of allegations due to mistaken identity or insufficient evidence. Even by later standards, Dash argues, the evidence of guilt for many thugs was often overwhelming.<ref name="mikedash" /> Because they used boats and disposed of their victims in rivers,<ref>Template:Cite book</ref> the "River Thugs" were able to evade the British authorities for some time after their compatriots on land were suppressed. They were ultimately betrayed to the authorities by one of their compatriots, from Awadh. Forces under Sleeman's command hunted them down in 1836.<ref name="Mike Dash 249">Template:Cite book</ref>
In 1870s the practice of thuggee was thought to have ceased. However, the history of Thuggee led to the Criminal Tribes Act (CTA) of 1871. Although the CTA was repealed at Indian independence in 1947, tribes considered criminal still exist in India.<ref>{{#invoke:citation/CS1|citation |CitationClass=web }}</ref><ref>Sinister sects: Thug, Mike Dash's investigation into the gangs who preyed on travellers in 19th-century India by Kevin Rushby, The Guardian, Saturday, 11 June 2005.</ref> The Thuggee and Dacoity Department remained in existence until 1904, when it was replaced by the Central Criminal Intelligence Department (CID).Template:Sfn
In Following the Equator, Mark Twain wrote about an 1839 government report by William Henry Sleeman:<ref name=Twain/>
Thug beliefsEdit
_-_Copy.jpg){kind=link}
Thugs considered themselves to be the children of Kali, having been created from her sweat.<ref>Template:Cite book</ref> However, many of the Thugs who were captured and convicted by the British were Muslims,<ref>Template:Cite book</ref> perhaps up to a third.<ref name="mikedash"/>Template:Page needed
According to colonial sources, Thugs believed that they played a positive role in saving human lives. Without the Thugs' sacred service, Kali might destroy all mankind:
- "It is God who kills, but Bhowanee has [a] name for it."
- "God is all in all, for good and evil."
- "God has appointed blood for [Bhowanee's] food, saying 'khoon tum khao': feed thou upon blood. In my opinion it is very bad, but what can she do, being ordered to subsist upon blood!"
- "Bhowanee is happy and more so in proportion to the blood that is shed."<ref name="WœrkensTihanyi2002">Template:Cite book</ref>
The Muslim thugs, while retaining their monotheistic faith, had functionalised Bhavani for Thuggee and she was syncretised as a spirit subordinate to Allah. A Muslim thug caught by Sleeman stated, "In my heart, I take the name of God, when I strangle a man – saying "God thou are King!" "Alla, toomee Malik!" I do not pray to Bhowanee, but I worship her." Other Muslim Thugs who had agreed to testify for Sleeman, stated they had assimilated Bhavani and started the practice of Thuggee.Template:Sfn
In the view of the historian Mike Dash, the Thuggee had no religious motivation in their murderous conduct. When religious elements were present among Thugs, their beliefs, in principle, were little different from the religious beliefs of many others who lived on the Indian subcontinent and attributed their success or failure to supernatural powers: "Indeed all of the Thugs's legends which concerned the goddess Kali featured exactly the cautionary notes which are typically found in folklore."<ref name="mikedash"/>
Kim Wagner asserts that we can analyse their traditions about events after their flight from Delhi "to a much greater advantage". A tradition which was recounted by a captive stated that Thuggee had originally tried to settle in Agra and they later settled in Akoopore in the Doab region. However, they had to flee to Himmutpur and later they fled to Parihara after their kings started demanding a larger share of the plunder. In turn the original Muslim and Kayastha Thugs helped spread Thuggee amongst other groups like the Brahmins, Rajputs, other Hindus, the Lodhi people and the Ahir people.Template:Sfn
The Thuggee generally considered that it was forbidden to kill women, fakirs, ascetics, bards, musicians and dancers.<ref>Template:Cite book</ref> Like the ancient Hindu texts which distinguished robbery from the murder of Brahmins, women or children as violent crimes, many Thugs considered it taboo to kill people who belonged to such categories.<ref>Template:Cite book</ref> Those who worked in lowly professions, the diseased and disabled were also forbidden as victims based on their folk belief.<ref>Template:Cite book</ref> The Thuggee cults believed that breaking these rules would incur divine retribution.<ref>Template:Cite book</ref>
GroupsEdit
The East India Company officers since the time of Thomas Perry, who was appointed to Etawah in 1811, came to understand that there were many Thuggee groups and they all viewed themselves to be different from the other groups.<ref>Template:Cite book</ref>
The Thuggee groups were often formed based on their native hometown, although some were also formed based on their professions. The group called "Jamuldahee" was named so because its members lived along the Yamuna river, they hailed from the Doab and Awadh regions. Another stated origin is that their ancestor was the Thuggee Jumulud Deen. The Telinganie originated from Telangana, Arcottees from Arcot and Beraries from Berar. The "Lodaha" group, mostly concentrated in Bihar, were caravaneers named after the lodha or load they carried and according to a Thuggee from the Doab, originated from the same ancestors of his clan. The Lodahas were prevalent in the region around Nepal in Bihar and Bengal during the tenure of Perry and originally hailed from Awadh which they left around 1700. A Deccan Thuggee stated that the "Hindu Thugs of Talghat", located around the Krishna River, didn't marry with the Telinganies whom they considered to be descendants of lower classes as a result of their professions.<ref>Template:Cite book</ref><ref>Template:Cite book</ref> The "Telinganie" group were also disparagingly called Handeewuls (from handi) due to their eating habits.<ref>Template:Cite book</ref>
The Pungoo or Bungoo of Bengal derived their name from the region, with the Lodhees or Lodaha also present. The Motheea group of Rampur-Purnia region was from a caste of weavers and their name derived from the practice of giving "handful" (muhti) of the spoils to the head. In the modern-day Uttar Pradesh, the groups were: the "Korkureeas" from Kohrur, "Agureeas" of Agra, "Jumaldahees", "Lodhees" and "Tundals". The "Multaneea" were from Multan. In Madhya Pradesh, the groups were: "Bangureeas" or "Banjaras", "Balheems" or "Bulheems", "Khokhureeas" and "Soopurreeas" of Sheopur. In modern Rajasthan, the groups were "Guguras" whose name derives from river Ghaggar, and the "Sooseeas" who were part of the Dhanuk clan. The "Dhoulanee" group existed in modern-day Maharashtra. The "Duckunies" of Deccan were from Munirabad and "Kurnaketies" from the Carnatic region. Another group was called "Kathurs" whose name derives from a bowl called kathota, based on a tradition of a man who held it during celebrations by Thugs. The "Qulundera" group's name was derived from the Muslim saints called qalandar. There were also Jogi thugs who were divided into twelve sub-groups.<ref>Template:Cite book</ref>
According to Feringheea, the Brahmins of Tehngoor village of Parihar were taught Thuggee after they accompanied the kings of Meos to Delhi, and later helped in spreading it in the region around Murnae. He also stated that two of his ancestors had settled and intermarried with Brahmins of Murnae about seven generations ago, which led to the introduction of Thuggee in the area. A thug hailing from Shikohabad whilst talking of his clan's origin, recounted to Perry a tradition that the Munhars were influenced to take up Thuggee after witnessing the immense plunder acquired by Afghans, Mewatties and the Sheikhs.Template:Sfn
Sleeman in 1839 identified a band called "Meypunnaists" who he stated abducted children to sell them further. Another band called "Tashmabazes" who used methods introduced by a soldier named Creagh who was deployed at Cawnpore in 1802 were also identified by him.<ref>Template:Cite book</ref> The group called "River Thugs" were based deep in the Hooghly region.<ref name="Mike Dash 249"/>
Historical evaluationsEdit
Worship of Kali was particularly emphasized by the British contemporaries. McLeod commented, "It is a notable fact that not only amongst the Thugs, but in an especial manner among all lawless fraternities, and to a certain extent throughout the uneducated population of Central India, the Mussulmans vie with the Hindus in a devotion of this sanguinary deity (Devi or Bhavani) far exceeding that they pay to any other."Template:Sfn Sleeman thought that some Brahmins acted as intelligence providers to thugs, claiming that they profited from Thuggee and directed it.<ref name="University of California Press">Template:Cite book</ref> David Ochterlony blamed the Pindaris for the rise of Thuggee while Sleeman blamed it on Indian rulers dismissing their armies which took away the jobs of many soldiers.Template:Sfn Based on Sleeman's writings about the Thugs, Robert Vane Russell claimed that most of them were Kanjars. He viewed the Muslim Kanjars as having recently converted to Islam.<ref name="Martine van Woerkens 136"/>
The British generally took the view that Thuggee was a type of ritual murder practiced by worshippers of Kali. Sleeman's view of it as an aberrant faith was based on the contemporary British view that Hinduism was a despicable and immoral faith founded on idol-worship.<ref name="Will Sweetman, Aditya Malik">Template:Cite book</ref> R. C. Sherwood in Asiatick Researches published in 1820 traces this phenomenon back to the Muslim conquests of India and suggests links to Hindu mythology.<ref>Template:Cite book</ref> Charles Trevelyan viewed Thugs as representatives of the "essence" of Hinduism (rather than as a deviant sect), which he considered to be "evil" and "false".<ref>Template:Cite book</ref>
In 1882, Alexander Cunningham commented on Hiouen-Thsang's remarks about "people who visited Kahalgaon and forgot to leave it", speculating that the actual reason might not have been that posited by the monk and noting Kahalgaon's later reputation as a place frequented by the "River Thugs".<ref name="Martine van Woerkens 2002 110"/>
Modern scepticismEdit
Modern contemporary scholars have become increasingly sceptical of the "thuggee" concept, and have even questioned the existence of such a phenomenon.<ref name="Cambridge Scholars Publishing">Template:Cite book</ref><ref name="ReferenceA">Template:Cite journal</ref><ref name="S. Shankar 2001"/> The British representation of Thuggee is held by some critics to be full of inconsistencies and exaggerations. Numerous historians have described "thuggee" as basically the invention of the British colonial regime.<ref>Template:Cite book</ref> However, the more radical critics in this camp have themselves been criticized for focusing overly on British perceptions of thuggee rather than on the historical accuracy of primary source documents, but conclude that "the colonial representation of thuggee cannot be taken at face value".Template:Sfn
Martine van Woerkens of École Pratique des Hautes Études writes that evidence for a Thuggee group in the 19th century was the product of "colonial imaginings", arising from British fear of the little-known interior of India, as well as limited understanding of the religious and social practices of its inhabitants.<ref name="woerkens">van Woerkens, Martine (2002). The Strangled Traveler: Colonial Imaginings and the Thugs of India.</ref>
Cynthia Ann Humes states that the testimony of most of the thugs captured by Sleeman does not support his view of priests profiting from and directing the thugs. She adds that the Islamic idea of fate was more commonly invoked during Thuggee acts, while invoking the Hindu Bhavani was far more rare.<ref name="University of California Press" />
Historian Kim Wagner views the policies of East India Company in relation to the dismissal of armies of the conquered Indian kingdoms as being responsible for the development of Thuggee. Roaming bands of freelance soldiers had often joined one kingdom or another during the pre-British era, with the main income of many armies coming from plunder. After being dismissed from military service, they turned to robbery as a means of subsistence.Template:Sfn He also contested whether the thugs mentioned by Firuz Shah Tughlaq's biography were actually the same thugs the British authorities fought against.Template:Sfn
Sagnik Bhattacharya agrees with the sceptics and claims the thug-phenomenon to be nothing but a manifestation of the fear of the unknown that dawned on the British Raj at the thought of being alone in the wilderness of Central India. Using literary and legal sources, he has connected the "information panic" of the thug-phenomenon to the limitations of British demographic models that fell short of truly capturing the ethnic diversity of India. He explains the "Thuggee hysteria" around 1830s as being caused by the Raj's angst at realizing its own ignorance of local society.<ref>Template:Cite journal</ref>
In popular cultureEdit
- One of the c. 1600 Janamsakhis fictionalizing the life of Sikh Guru Nanak describes an encounter with a Thug, Sheikh Sajjan, whom the guru reforms.<ref>Template:Cite thesis</ref>
- The 1826 novel Pandurang Hari, or Memoirs of a Hindoo by William Browne Hockley provides in Chapter 11 the earliest British fictional account of the Thugs.<ref>"Were Thugs of India religious terrorists or mere bandits? The evidence of Hockley’s Pandurang Hari" by Ayusman Chakraborty, Academia Letters, Article 198, January 2021.</ref> But they are depicted only as thieves, not as murderers.
- The 1839 novel Confessions of a Thug by Philip Meadows Taylor is based on the Thuggee cult, revolving around a fictional Thuggee who is named Ameer<ref>History of Ameer Ali Thug</ref> Ali. The novel popularized the word "thug" in the English language.
- Thuggees, including Faringhea himself, play a substantial role in the 1845 novel, The Wandering Jew by Eugene Sue.
- Several of Emilio Salgari's Sandokan novels describe a struggle with the Thugs. Many of his novels are about Sandokan's adventures, and feature the Thuggee as enemies of the heroes. The first of them – I misteri della jungla nera (1887) – was originally published with the title Gli strangolatori del Gange ("The Stranglers of the Ganges"). His novel I misteri della giungla nera (1895) revolves around the main character Tremal Naik's fight to save Ada Corisant, the daughter of a British officer, who has been kidnapped by the Thugs.
- The 1886 novel Kalee's Shrine by Grant Allen and May Cotes features a British female Thug.<ref>"Thuggee in England: Tracing the Origin and Development of Fantasies of Thug-invasion and Reverse Colonization in late nineteenth century British Fiction" by Ayusman Chakraborty, ' ' Rupkatha Journal on Interdisciplinary Studies in Humanities ' ', vol. 13, no. 1. 2021.</ref>
- Sir Arthur Conan Doyle introduces the Thugs in his 1887 short story "Uncle Jeremy's Household". Miss Warrender, the Anglo-Indian governess in this story, is the daughter of the fictional Thuggee prince Achmet Genghis Khan.
- The 1931 crime novel The Case of the Frightened Lady by Edgar Wallace makes an indirect reference to the Thuggee murders by featuring "Indian scarves" which are used as murder weapons, as do its 1940 and 1963 West German film adaptations.
- The 1939 film Gunga Din features British soldiers' conflict with a resurgent sect of Thuggee cultists.
- The Thuggees and their method of killing are made reference to in the 1945 film Hangover Square.
- The Stranglers of Bombay (1959) is a film which is centered around a lone British officer who investigates and uncovers the doings of the Thuggee cult.
- Kali Yug, la dea della vendetta and Il mistero del tempio indiano, films by Mario Camerini (1963), feature Klaus Kinski as Thug leader.
- Help! (1965), a film which revolves around The Beatles' encounters with an Eastern Cult, is thought to parody the Thuggee.<ref name="Magic Circles">Template:Cite book</ref><ref name="Vampires' Most Wanted">Template:Cite book</ref>
- In Our Man Flint (1966), the character Derek Flint wears a turban and shouts "Kali!" while shooting a gun into the air in order to safely empty a club of its patrons before setting off an explosive.<ref>{{#invoke:citation/CS1|citation
|CitationClass=web }}</ref>
- Sunghursh (1968), an Indian Hindi film, gives a fictionalized account of a Thuggee who tries not to join his family business, which is Thuggee.
- Thagini (1974) an Indian Bengali-language film about a lady Thug, directed by Tarun Majumdar and based on a short story of Subodh Ghosh.
- Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom (1984), set in 1935, showcases the Thuggee cult with fictionalized religious ritual and the primary antagonist, Mola Ram, being a Thuggee High Priest of Kali.<ref>Template:Cite book</ref>
- The Black Company (1984–present), a dark fantasy series by Glen Cook, features a cult called the Deceivers, largely based on the Thuggee, which plays a major role in the later novels.
- The fictional DC Comics villain Ravan (starting 1987), a member of the Suicide Squad, is a modern-day member of the Thuggee cult.
- The Deceivers (1988) is an adventure film about the murderous Thugs of India which is based on the 1952 John Masters novel with the same name. Pierce Brosnan plays William Savage, a tax-collector for a British-Indian company who goes under cover in 1825 to investigate a Thuggee sect.
- Ameer Ali thug na peela rumal ni gaanth, a novel in three parts by the famous Gujarati thriller writer Harkisan Mehta, is a fictionalized account of the Thuggee Amir Ali, with references to the infamous Pindari chief Chitu Pindari.
- Theeran Adhigaaram Ondru (2017; Tamil) an honest police officer finds himself transferred again and again due to his sincerity. After his latest transfer, he comes across a file that involves a gang of ruthless thieves who loot and kill along the highway. A group of 13 people whose roots go back to these Thuggee tribes whose members camouflaged themselves as logistics and goods delivery vendors and plundered random cities and brutally murdered families, including women and children. Tamil Nadu Police took this matter seriously when a member of the legislative assembly was victimized. This cult was brought down after a country-wide operation was conducted with limited resources for over 18 months.
- Thugs of Hindostan (2018), an Indian Hindi-language action-adventure film about a band of Thugs which resists the British East India Company's rule in India. The film stars Amitabh Bachchan, Aamir Khan, Katrina Kaif, Fatima Sana Shaikh and Lloyd Owen.
- The Strangler Vine (2014) by MJ Carter, a novel set in Calcutta in 1837, sees two representatives of the East India Company search for a missing author deep within the territory of the murderous Kali-worshipping Thugs.
- Grimm (2014), in season 4, episode 6, entitled "Highway of Tears", Nick, Hank, and Wu confront a "Phansigar," a Wesen that worships Kali with a sacrifice, every 3 years.
- Firingi Thagi (2015), a Bengali-language novel by Indian author Himadri Kishor Dashgupta, is a fictionalized rendering of Sir William Henry Sleeman's operations against the Thugs.
- Ebong Inquisition, a Bengali-language novel series by Indian writer Avik Sarkar, also features events in which the Thuggees are the key participants, with references to Sleeman, Feringhea, Khuda Baksh.
- The strategy game Age of Empires III: The Asian Dynasties features Thuggees and dacoits, both of whom are available to players as hired mercenaries, though they are somewhat inaccurately depicted as using pistols and musket.
- Thugs of Ramaghada (2022), an Indian Kannada-language film based on band of Thugs who try to rob rich gangsters, directed by Karthik Maralabhavi and starring Ashwin Hassan, Chandan Raj and Mahalakshmi
- In Highlander: The Series season 4 episode 9, "The Wrath of Kali", the immortal Kamir is presented as the last of a Thuggee cult who tries to steal a statue of the Hindu goddess Kali and murder the half-Indian professor who acquired it for her university.
- In 2018 there was an episode in CID based on this group
See alsoEdit
ReferencesEdit
BibliographyEdit
- Template:Cite EB1911
- Dash, Mike Thug: the true story of Indias murderous cult Template:ISBN, 2005
- Template:Citation. First published in 1986, Template:ISBN.
- Dutta, Krishna (2005) The sacred slaughterers. Book review of Thug: the true story of India's murderous cult by Mike Dash. In The Independent (Published: 8 July 2005) text
- Template:Citation.
- Guidolin, Monica "Gli strangolatori di Kali. Il culto thag tra immaginario e realtà storica", Aurelia Edizioni, 2012, Template:ISBN.
- Paton, James 'Collections on Thuggee and Dacoitee', British Library, Add MS 41300
- Woerkens, Martine van The Strangled Traveler: Colonial Imaginings and the Thugs of India (2002),
- Wagner, Kim, Stranglers and Bandits: A Historical Anthology of Thuggee (2009), Oxford University Press
External linksEdit
- Acting in the "Theatre of Anarchy": 'The Anti-Thug Campaign' and Elaborations of Colonial Rule in Early-Nineteenth Century India by Tom Lloyd (2006) in PDF file format
- Parama Roy: Discovering India, Imagining Thuggee. In: idem, Indian Traffic. Identities in Question in Colonial and Postcolonial India. University of California Press 1998. (in html format)
- Confessions of India's real-life Thugs
- Template:Cite book
- Template:Cite book