Editing Common Sense (section)

==Publication==
[[File:Thomas Paine rev1.jpg|thumb|[[Thomas Paine]] depicted in a portrait by [[Laurent Dabos]], {{circa|1792}}]]
Paine arrived in the [[Thirteen Colonies|American colonies]] in November 1774, shortly before the [[Battles of Lexington and Concord]]. Though the colonies and [[Great Britain]] had commenced hostilities against one another, the thought of independence was not initially entertained. Writing in 1778 of his early experiences in the colonies, Paine "found the disposition of the people such that they might have been led by a thread and governed by a reed. Their attachment to Britain was obstinate, and it was, at that time, a kind of treason to speak against it. Their ideas of grievance operated without resentment, and their single object was reconciliation."<ref>{{harvp|Gimbel|1956|p=15}}</ref> Paine quickly engrained himself in the Philadelphia newspaper business, and began writing ''Common Sense'' in late 1775 under the working title of ''Plain Truth''. Though it began as a series of letters to be published in various Philadelphia papers, it grew too long and unwieldy to publish as letters, leading Paine to select the pamphlet form.<ref>{{harvp|Gimbel|1956|p=17}}</ref>

[[Benjamin Rush]] recommended the publisher [[Robert Bell (publisher)|Robert Bell]], promising Paine that although other printers might balk at the content of the pamphlet, Bell would not hesitate or delay its printing. The pamphlet was first published on January 10, 1776.<ref name="Paine Britannica"/> Bell zealously promoted the pamphlet in Philadelphia's papers, and demand grew so high as to require a second printing.<ref name="auto">{{harvp|Gimbel|1956|p=21}}</ref> Paine, overjoyed with its success, endeavored to collect his share of the profits and donate them to purchase mittens for General Montgomery's troops, then encamped in frigid Quebec.<ref>{{harvp|Gimbel|1956|p=22}}</ref> However, when Paine's chosen intermediaries audited Bell's accounts, they found that the pamphlet actually had made zero profits. Incensed, Paine ordered Bell not to proceed on a second edition, as he had planned several appendices to add to ''Common Sense''. Bell ignored that and began advertising a "new edition."<ref>{{citation |last = Burchell |first = Kenneth |title = Thomas Paine and America 1776-1809 |publisher = Routledge |date=2010 }}</ref>

The advertisement backfired, despite Bell's hopes that it would persuade Paine to continue using his services. Paine secured the assistance of the Bradford brothers, publishers of ''[[The Pennsylvania Evening Post]]'', and released his new edition, featuring several appendices and additional writings.<ref>{{harvp|Gimbel|1956|p=23}}</ref> Bell began working on a second edition. This set off a month-long public debate between Bell and the still-anonymous Paine, conducted within the pages and advertisements of the ''Pennsylvania Evening Post'', with each party charging the other with duplicity and fraud. Paine and Bell published several more editions through the end of their public squabble. {{Citation needed|date=January 2017}}

The publicity generated by the initial success and compounded by the publishing disagreements propelled the pamphlet to incredible sales and circulation. Following Paine's own estimate of the pamphlet's sales, some historians claim that ''Common Sense'' sold almost 100,000 copies in 1776,<ref>{{Harvp|Foot|Kramnick|1987|p=10}}</ref> and according to Paine, 120,000 copies were sold in the first three months. One biographer estimates that 500,000 copies were sold in the first year (in both America and Europe, predominantly France and Britain), and another writes that Paine's pamphlet went through 25 published editions in the first year alone.<ref name=" Wood55" /><ref>Isaac Kramnick, "Introduction", in Thomas Paine, ''Common Sense'' (New York: Penguin, 1986), p. 8</ref> However, some historians dispute these figures as implausible because of the literate population at the time and estimated the far upper limit as 75,000 copies.<ref>Trish Loughran, ''The Republic in Print: Print Culture in the Age of U.S. Nation Building, 1770–1870'' (New York: Columbia University Press, 2007)</ref><ref>{{Cite news|url=https://allthingsliberty.com/2013/03/thomas-paines-inflated-numbers/|title=Thomas Paine's Inflated Numbers|last=Raphael|first=Ray|date=20 March 2013|work=Journal of the American Revolution|access-date=22 January 2019}}</ref>

Aside from the printed pamphlet itself, there were many handwritten summaries and whole copies circulated. Paine also granted publishing rights to nearly every imprint which requested them, including several international editions.<ref name="auto1">{{harvp|Gimbel|1956|p=57}}</ref> It was immensely popular in France, where it was published without its diatribes against monarchy.<ref>{{Harvp|Foot|Kramnick|1987|pp=10–11}}</ref> At least one newspaper printed the entire pamphlet: the ''[[Connecticut Courant]]'' in its issue of February 19, 1776.<ref>{{Harvp|Aldridge|1984|p=45}}</ref> Writing in 1956, Richard Gimbel estimated, in terms of circulation and impact, that an "equivalent sale today, based on the present population of the United States, would be more than six-and-one-half million copies within the short space of three months".<ref name="auto1"/>

For nearly three months, Paine managed to maintain his anonymity, even during Bell's potent newspaper polemics. His name did not become officially connected with the independence controversy until March 30, 1776.<ref name="Aldridge43">{{harvp|Aldridge|1984|p=43}}</ref> Paine never recouped the profits that he felt were due to him from Bell's first edition. Ultimately, he lost money on the Bradford printing as well, and because he decided to repudiate his copyright, he never profited from ''Common Sense''.{{Citation needed|date=January 2017}}