Editing NACDA Directors' Cup (section)

===NAIA===

{| class="wikitable" style="width:100%"
|-
! style="width:15%" | Year
! style="width:17%" | First
! style="width:17%" | Second
! style="width:17%" | Third
! style="width:17%" | Fourth
! style="width:17%" | Fifth
|-
! 1995–96
| [[Pacific Lutheran Lutes|Pacific Lutheran]]
| [[Simon Fraser Red Leafs|Simon Fraser]]
| [[Mobile Rams|Mobile]]
| [[Berry Vikings|Berry]]
| [[Azusa Pacific Cougars|Azusa Pacific]]
|-
! 1996–97
| Simon Fraser
| Pacific Lutheran
| Azusa Pacific
| Mobile
| [[Willamette Bearcats|Willamette]]
|-
! 1997–98
| Simon Fraser
| Mobile
| [[Findlay Oilers|Findlay]]
| [[Oklahoma City Stars|Oklahoma City]]
| [[Puget Sound Loggers|Puget Sound]]
|-
! 1998–99
| Simon Fraser
| Azusa Pacific
| [[Life Running Eagles|Life]]
| colspan="2" | (tie) Oklahoma City; [[Lindenwood Lions|Lindenwood]]
|-
! 1999–2000
| Simon Fraser
| Lindenwood
| Azusa Pacific
| [[Mary Marauders|Mary]]
| Oklahoma City
|-
! 2000–01
| Simon Fraser
| Oklahoma City
| Azusa Pacific
| Lindenwood
| [[University of the Cumberlands#Athletics|Cumberlands (KY)]]
|-
! 2001–02
| Oklahoma City
| Lindenwood
| Simon Fraser
| Azusa Pacific
| [[Malone Pioneers|Malone]]
|-
! 2002–03
| Lindenwood
| Simon Fraser
| Azusa Pacific
| Mary
| Oklahoma City
|-
! 2003–04
| Simon Fraser
| Azusa Pacific
| Lindenwood
| Oklahoma City
| (tie) Mary; [[Dickinson State Blue Hawks|Dickinson State]]
|-
! 2004–05
| Azusa Pacific
| Lindenwood
| Simon Fraser
| [[Point Loma Sea Lions|Point Loma Nazarene]]
| Mary
|-
! 2005–06
| Azusa Pacific
| Lindenwood
| [[Lindsey Wilson Blue Raiders|Lindsey Wilson]]
| [[Oklahoma Baptist Bison|Oklahoma Baptist]]
| Simon Fraser
|-
! 2006–07
| Azusa Pacific
| Lindenwood
| [[Concordia Eagles|Concordia (CA)]]
| [[Cedarville Yellow Jackets|Cedarville]]
| Oklahoma Baptist
|-
! 2007–08
| Azusa Pacific
| Simon Fraser
| [[Embry–Riddle Eagles|Embry–Riddle]]
| [[Fresno Pacific Sunbirds|Fresno Pacific]]
| Concordia (CA)
|-
! 2008–09
| Azusa Pacific
| Concordia (CA)
| Lindenwood
| Fresno Pacific
| [[California Baptist Lancers|California Baptist]]
|-
! 2009–10
| Azusa Pacific
| Simon Fraser
| Fresno Pacific
| Concordia (CA)
| Lindenwood
|-
! 2010–11
| Azusa Pacific
| Embry–Riddle
| [[Shorter Hawks|Shorter]]
| Fresno Pacific
| Lindenwood
|-
! 2011–12
| Azusa Pacific
| Shorter
| Embry–Riddle
| Oklahoma Baptist
| Lindsey Wilson
|-
! 2012–13
| Oklahoma Baptist
| Lindsey Wilson
| Concordia (CA)
| Embry–Riddle (FL)
| [[Olivet Nazarene Tigers|Olivet Nazarene]]
|-
! 2013–14
| [[Grand View Vikings|Grand View]]
| Oklahoma City
| Lindsey Wilson
| Embry–Riddle
| Olivet Nazarene
|-
! 2014–15
| Oklahoma Baptist
| Lindsey Wilson
| Oklahoma City
| [[Wayland Baptist Pioneers|Wayland Baptist]]
| Embry–Riddle
|-
! 2015–16
| Lindsey Wilson
| Oklahoma Baptist
| Wayland Baptist
| Olivet Nazarene
| [[Indiana Wesleyan Wildcats|Indiana Wesleyan]]
|-
! 2016–17
| Oklahoma City
| Lindsey Wilson
| [[Keiser Seahawks|Keiser]]
| Wayland Baptist
| [[William Carey Crusaders|William Carey]]
|-
! 2017–18
| Oklahoma City
| Lindsey Wilson
| Wayland Baptist
| Keiser
| Indiana Wesleyan
|-
! 2018–19
| Oklahoma City
| William Carey
| Lindsey Wilson
| Keiser
| Indiana Wesleyan
|-
!2019–20
| colspan="5" |''Not awarded because of the [[COVID-19 pandemic in the United States|COVID-19 pandemic]]''<ref name=":0" />{{Efn|At the time of the competition being canceled the top 5 was as follows: Lindsey Wilson, Indiana Wesleyan, [[Eastern Oregon University#Athletics|Eastern Oregon]], Grand View, Cumberlands (KY)<ref>{{Cite web |title=March 2020 NAIA Learfield IMG College Directors’ Cup Standings|url=https://nacda.com/news/2020/3/12/directorscup-naia-learfield-img-college-directors-cup-standings.aspx|access-date=2022-11-20 |website=National Association of Collegiate Directors of Athletics |language=en}}</ref>|group=2020 naia}}
|-
!2020–21
|Keiser
|[[Indiana Tech Warriors|Indiana Tech]]
| Indiana Wesleyan
|Oklahoma City
|[[Marian Knights|Marian (IN)]]
|-
!2021–22
|Indiana Wesleyan
|Keiser
|Grand View
|Indiana Tech
|[[Southeastern Fire|Southeastern (FL)]]
|-
!2022–23<ref name=":3" />
|Indiana Tech
|Marian (IN)
|Keiser
|Indiana Wesleyan
|Southeastern (FL)
|-
! 2023–24<ref name=202324Winners/>
| Cumberlands
| Indiana Wesleyan
| Keiser
| Marian
| William Carey
|}
{{notelist|group=2020 naia}}

Schools in ''italics'' no longer compete in the NAIA.
{| class="wikitable sortable"
|+
!University
!Cup wins
|-
| ''Azusa Pacific''
| 8
|-
| ''Simon Fraser''
| 6
|-
| Oklahoma City
| 4
|-
| ''Oklahoma Baptist''
| 2
|-
| Cumberlands
| 1
|-
| Grand View
| 1
|-
| Indiana Tech
| 1
|-
| Indiana Wesleyan
| 1
|-
| Keiser
| 1
|-
| ''Lindenwood''
| 1
|-
| Lindsey Wilson
| 1
|-
| ''Pacific Lutheran''
| 1
|}