Open main menu
Home
Random
Recent changes
Special pages
Community portal
Preferences
About Wikipedia
Disclaimers
Incubator escapee wiki
Search
User menu
Talk
Dark mode
Contributions
Create account
Log in
Editing
Brouwer fixed-point theorem
(section)
Warning:
You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you
log in
or
create an account
, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.
Anti-spam check. Do
not
fill this in!
=== A proof using the hairy ball theorem === The [[hairy ball theorem]] states that on the unit sphere {{mvar|''S''}} in an odd-dimensional Euclidean space, there is no nowhere-vanishing continuous tangent vector field {{mvar|'''w'''}} on {{mvar|''S''}}. (The tangency condition means that {{mvar|'''w'''('''x''') β '''x'''}} = 0 for every unit vector {{mvar|'''x'''}}.) Sometimes the theorem is expressed by the statement that "there is always a place on the globe with no wind". An elementary proof of the hairy ball theorem can be found in {{harvtxt|Milnor|1978}}. In fact, suppose first that {{mvar|'''w'''}} is ''continuously differentiable''. By scaling, it can be assumed that {{mvar|'''w'''}} is a continuously differentiable unit tangent vector on {{mvar|'''S'''}}. It can be extended radially to a small spherical shell {{mvar|''A''}} of {{mvar|''S''}}. For {{mvar|''t''}} sufficiently small, a routine computation shows that the mapping {{mvar|'''f'''<sub>''t''</sub>}}({{mvar|'''x'''}}) = {{mvar|'''x'''}} + {{mvar|''t'' '''w'''('''x''')}} is a [[contraction mapping]] on {{mvar|''A''}} and that the volume of its image is a polynomial in {{mvar|''t''}}. On the other hand, as a contraction mapping, {{mvar|'''f'''<sub>''t''</sub>}} must restrict to a homeomorphism of {{mvar|''S''}} onto (1 + {{mvar|''t''<sup>2</sup>}})<sup>{{sfrac|1|2}}</sup> {{mvar|''S''}} and {{mvar|''A''}} onto (1 + {{mvar|''t''<sup>2</sup>}})<sup>{{sfrac|1|2}}</sup> {{mvar|''A''}}. This gives a contradiction, because, if the dimension {{mvar|''n''}} of the Euclidean space is odd, (1 + {{mvar|''t''<sup>2</sup>}})<sup>{{mvar|''n''}}/2</sup> is not a polynomial. If {{mvar|'''w'''}} is only a ''continuous'' unit tangent vector on {{mvar|''S''}}, by the [[Weierstrass approximation theorem]], it can be uniformly approximated by a polynomial map {{mvar|'''u'''}} of {{mvar|''A''}} into Euclidean space. The orthogonal projection on to the tangent space is given by {{mvar|'''v'''}}({{mvar|'''x'''}}) = {{mvar|'''u'''}}({{mvar|'''x'''}}) - {{mvar|'''u'''}}({{mvar|'''x'''}}) β {{mvar|'''x'''}}. Thus {{mvar|'''v'''}} is polynomial and nowhere vanishing on {{mvar|''A''}}; by construction {{mvar|'''v'''}}/||{{mvar|'''v'''}}|| is a smooth unit tangent vector field on {{mvar|''S''}}, a contradiction. The continuous version of the hairy ball theorem can now be used to prove the Brouwer fixed point theorem. First suppose that {{mvar|''n''}} is even. If there were a fixed-point-free continuous self-mapping {{mvar|'''f'''}} of the closed unit ball {{mvar|''B''}} of the {{mvar|''n''}}-dimensional Euclidean space {{mvar|''V''}}, set :<math>{\mathbf w}({\mathbf x}) = (1 - {\mathbf x}\cdot {\mathbf f}({\mathbf x}))\, {\mathbf x} - (1 - {\mathbf x}\cdot {\mathbf x})\, {\mathbf f}({\mathbf x}).</math> Since {{mvar|'''f'''}} has no fixed points, it follows that, for {{mvar|'''x'''}} in the [[interior (topology)|interior]] of {{mvar|''B''}}, the vector {{mvar|'''w'''}}({{mvar|'''x'''}}) is non-zero; and for {{mvar|'''x'''}} in {{mvar|''S''}}, the scalar product <br/> {{mvar|'''x'''}} β {{mvar|'''w'''}}({{mvar|'''x'''}}) = 1 β {{mvar|'''x'''}} β {{mvar|'''f'''}}({{mvar|'''x'''}}) is strictly positive. From the original {{mvar|''n''}}-dimensional space Euclidean space {{mvar|''V''}}, construct a new auxiliary <br/>({{mvar|''n'' + 1}})-dimensional space {{mvar|''W''}} = {{mvar|''V''}} x '''R''', with coordinates {{mvar|''y''}} = ({{mvar|'''x'''}}, {{mvar|''t''}}). Set :<math>{\mathbf X}({\mathbf x},t)=(-t\,{\mathbf w}({\mathbf x}), {\mathbf x}\cdot {\mathbf w}({\mathbf x})).</math> By construction {{mvar|'''X'''}} is a continuous vector field on the unit sphere of {{mvar|''W''}}, satisfying the tangency condition {{mvar|'''y'''}} β {{mvar|'''X'''}}({{mvar|'''y'''}}) = 0. Moreover, {{mvar|'''X'''}}({{mvar|'''y'''}}) is nowhere vanishing (because, if {{var|'''x'''}} has norm 1, then {{mvar|'''x'''}} β {{mvar|'''w'''}}({{mvar|''x''}}) is non-zero; while if {{mvar|'''x'''}} has norm strictly less than 1, then {{mvar|''t''}} and {{mvar|'''w'''}}({{mvar|'''x'''}}) are both non-zero). This contradiction proves the fixed point theorem when {{mvar|''n''}} is even. For {{mvar|''n''}} odd, one can apply the fixed point theorem to the closed unit ball {{mvar|''B''}} in {{mvar|''n'' + 1}} dimensions and the mapping {{mvar|'''F'''}}({{mvar|'''x'''}},{{mvar|''y''}}) = ({{mvar|'''f'''}}({{mvar|'''x'''}}),0). The advantage of this proof is that it uses only elementary techniques; more general results like the [[Borsuk-Ulam theorem]] require tools from [[algebraic topology]].<ref name="Milnor78">{{harvnb|Milnor|1978}}</ref>
Edit summary
(Briefly describe your changes)
By publishing changes, you agree to the
Terms of Use
, and you irrevocably agree to release your contribution under the
CC BY-SA 4.0 License
and the
GFDL
. You agree that a hyperlink or URL is sufficient attribution under the Creative Commons license.
Cancel
Editing help
(opens in new window)