Editing Body mass index (section)

===Muscle versus fat===
Assumptions about the distribution between muscle mass and fat mass are inexact. BMI generally overestimates [[adipose tissue|adiposity]] on those with leaner body mass (e.g., athletes) and underestimates excess adiposity on those with fattier body mass.

A study in June 2008 by Romero-Corral et al. examined 13,601 subjects from the United States' third [[National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey]] (NHANES III) and found that BMI-defined obesity (BMI ≥ 30) was present in 21% of men and 31% of women. Body fat-defined obesity was found in 50% of men and 62% of women. While BMI-defined obesity showed high [[Sensitivity and specificity|specificity]] (95% for men and 99% for women), BMI showed poor [[Sensitivity and specificity|sensitivity]] (36% for men and 49% for women). In other words, the BMI will be mostly correct when determining a person to be obese, but can err quite frequently when determining a person not to be. Despite this undercounting of obesity by BMI, BMI values in the intermediate BMI range of 20–30 were found to be associated with a wide range of body fat percentages. For men with a BMI of 25, about 20% have a body fat percentage below 20% and about 10% have body fat percentage above 30%.<ref name="RomeroCorral2008"/>

Body composition for athletes is often better calculated using measures of body fat, as determined by such techniques as skinfold measurements or underwater weighing and the limitations of manual measurement have also led to alternative methods to measure obesity, such as the [[Classification of obesity#Body Volume Index|body volume indicator]].<ref>{{Cite journal |last1=Tahrani |first1=Abd |last2=Boelaert |first2=Kristien |last3=Barnes |first3=Richard |last4=Palin |first4=Suzanne |last5=Field |first5=Annmarie |last6=Redmayne |first6=Helen |last7=Aytok |first7=Lisa |last8=Rahim |first8=Asad |date=2008-04-01 |title=Body volume index: time to replace body mass index? |url=https://www.endocrine-abstracts.org/ea/0015/ea0015p104 |journal=Endocrine Abstracts |language=en |volume=15 |issn=1470-3947}}</ref>