Editing Incubator escapee wiki:WikiProject Philosophy/Tasks Archive 1

===Short-term tasks===

*'''Copyedit'''

*'''Peer review''' 
**[[School of Salamanca]] just translated from Spanish, mostly one author's work in the Spanish, no references, some possible Whig History (as discussed on [[Talk:School of Salamanca]], review heartily welcomed. -- [[User:Jmabel|Jmabel]] | [[User talk:Jmabel|Talk]] 07:43, Oct 15, 2004 (UTC)
**Could someone have a look at my question at [[Talk:Probabilism]]? -- [[User:Jmabel|Jmabel]] | [[User talk:Jmabel|Talk]] 07:43, Oct 15, 2004 (UTC)
**There is a long, slow edit war occurring at [[modus tollens]]. Perhaps comment by other users might help.
**[[Iamblichus (philosopher)]] - wrestling with the 1911 text, would appreciate comment--[[User:DanielCD|DanielCD]] 15:19, 7 Jul 2004 (UTC) 
**[[Philosophy of space and time]]
**[[Scientific method]] - updated
**[[Induction]] - included critique of Bayesian inference
**[[Metaphysical subjectivism]]
*** My intuition tells me that this needs peer review! A Google search for the term yields many copies of this article, so it's important that it's correct.
*** On the talk page, someone mentioned that 'metaphysical subjectivism' isn't a widely-used term. Should the article title be renamed to [[Subjectivism (philosophy)]]?
**** I would recommend just changing [[Subjectivism]] from a disambig into an article on subjectivism in philosophy, including the text from [[Ethical subjectivism]] and from [[Subject (philosophy)]], and then delete the two articles.  This article, though, seems to point at something beyond just the normal meaning of subjectivism, meaning maybe it should remain its own article.  It definitely needs some sourcing and rewriting, regardless of what we do with it.  -[[User:Sethmahoney|Seth Mahoney]] 22:14, Sep 17, 2004 (UTC)
*****Done. Merged into [[Subjectivism (philosophy)]]. I think the merge is much better, since the topics are intimately related, and people are often confuse the different meanings of 'subjectivism', including ourselves... [[User:Wikiwikifast|Wikiwikifast]] 03:05, 19 Sep 2004 (UTC)
** [[Objectivity]] - needs cleanup because of redundancies; perhaps merge with [[metaphysical objectivism]]? --[[User:Wikiwikifast|Wikiwikifast]] 03:05, 19 Sep 2004 (UTC)


*'''Revise''' 
**[[Critical rationalism]]
*** Ugly ugly ugly. Needs to be de-Larried and revised.
*** Volunteers:
**[[Knowledge]]
*** [[User:Banno|Banno]] did a few edits - more needed.
*** Volunteers:
**[[Definition]]
*** Appears to be part of Larry's text.
*** Volunteers:

*'''Merge''' 
**[[The problem of evil]] and [[Epicurean paradox]]

*'''Expand'''
** [[Transplant trade]] (currently on Organ Donation)
***Nothing on this bioethical problem prior to today, to do with the disparity of class. Read what I have written on it so far. 
***Volunteers: [[User:OldakQuill|OldakQuill]]
****Expanded. Please review and edit. There is some redundancy, b/c [[bioethics]] at least ''ought'' to cover "ethical issues in organ donation"  and [[organ donation]] ought to be more historical and factual than philosophical. [[User:Amicuspublilius|Amicuspublilius]] 03:23, 22 Jul 2004 (UTC)
**[[José Ortega y Gasset]]
*** I've translated this from the Spanish-language Wikipedia. It could use some fleshing out (including about Ortega y Gasset's politics) and the "Philosophy" section at the bottom is ''very'' weak, but it's all there was in the original. -- [[User:Jmabel|Jmabel]] 19:40, 20 May 2004 (UTC)
**[[Giles of Rome]]
***Currently a poorly written stub, and its on the [[Medieval philosophers]] box, meaning its a poorly written stub that's drawing attention!  Ack! -[[User:Sethmahoney|Seth Mahoney]] 18:13, Aug 2, 2004 (UTC)
***Volunteers:

*'''[[Wikipedia:WikiProject Philosophy/Exemplary Article|Pick an exemplary article]]'''. All WikiProjects are supposed to pick an exemplary article in their field that represents the highest standard to which we aspire, and I think it would be good for us to do so as well. Vote and discuss on the linked page. [[User:Adam Conover|<nowiki></nowiki>]] &mdash; [[User:Adam Conover | Adam Conover]] [[User talk:Adam Conover|&dagger;]] 20:43, Apr 12, 2004 (UTC)

===Mid-range tasks===

*'''Overhaul''' [[Mind-body problem]]
** This article is a major part of [[philosophy of mind]], but currently is dominated by [[User:Larry Sanger/Larry's Text|Larry's Text]].
** Date added: 4/11/04.
** '''Volunteers:''' [[User:Adam Conover|Adam Conover]]

*'''Expand''' [[Critique of Pure Reason]].
** There's precious little information right now on the ''Critique of Pure Reason''. This is obviously one of the foundational works of philosophy, so we need a page on it. It's a big job, though, so as much help as possible would be appreciated.
** '''Volunteers:''' [[User:Michael Voytinsky | Michael Voytinsky]], [[User:Adam Conover|<nowiki></nowiki>]] &mdash; [[User:Adam Conover | Adam Conover]] [[User talk:Adam Conover|&dagger;]]

*'''Expand''' [[Philosophical Investigations]]
** Need to discuss "Private Language" and "beetle-in-the-box"
** '''Volunteers:'''[[User:Sethmahoney|Seth Mahoney]] - did some general editing and organization.

*'''Expand stub''' [[Philosophy of psychology]]
**I copyedited this article a bit, but it still needs some meat to this article.
**'''Task added:''' April 10, 2004
**'''Volunteers:'''

*'''Expand''' [[Analytic philosophy]]
** This is closely related to [[Philosophy of language]]
**'''Task added:''' April 12, 2004
**'''Volunteers:'''

*'''Expand''' [[Nicomachean ethics]]
*Extremely stubby.
**'''Task added:''' April 12, 2004
**'''Volunteers:'''

*'''Overhaul & Copyedit''' [[Cognitive science]]
** POV, unprofessional conjectures
** Needs copyediting
** '''Volunteers:'''

*'''Overhaul & Expand''' [[Plato]]
** Please see [[Talk:Plato#Cleanup]]
** '''Task added:''' 4 Sep 2004
** '''Volunteers:'''

====Descartes' Work====
*'''Expand''' [[Meditations on First Philosophy]], [[Discourse on Method]],[[La Géométrie]]
**La Géométrie and Discourse on Method could use some work to unstub them; Meditations could go into more detail.
** '''Volunteers:'''
** '''Comments:'''

*'''Overhaul''' [[Metaphysics]]
** The vast array of metaphysics articles over wiki need to be reorganised sensibly; currently the articles have no coherant structure, especially on the subject of [[Problem of universals]].  Pages needing to be written/merged/correct/cleared up include: [[Tropes]], [[Aristotle's theory of universals]], [[D.M Armstrong]], [[Nominalism]], [[Metaphysics]], [[Problem of universals]], [[Resemblance Nominalism]], [[Natural Class Theory]], [[Modal Realism]].  Please add more.  Perhaps we should separate these into the various sub-disciplines of Metaphysics first?
** Furthermore, [[Substance]] and [[Properties]] should each be made into a disambiguation page.
** Date added: 23/11/04.
** '''Volunteers:'''

===Long-term tasks===
====Larry's Text part 1: cleanup====
'''[[User:Larry Sanger/Larry's Text|Larry's Text]]''' is a mess. None of the articles that he wrote are encyclopedaic -- rather, they're all lectures that are aimed at beginning undergraduates. They are thus conversational in tone, and often gloss over serious issues in philosophy. What's worse, they frequently take up space that should be devoted to serious examination of philosophical topics.

One tactic for how to deal with Larry's Text is to collect the original versions of the pieces (available through the page history of the pages linked to on [[User:Larry Sanger/Larry's Text|Larry's Text]]) and move them to the User_talk namespace. This allows us to start fresh without losing good material.

A better tactic, I think, is to gather the texts and put them in Wikisource.  See [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia_talk:WikiProject_Philosophy#Larry.27s_text_revisited Wikipedia_talk:WikiProject_Philosophy#Larry's_text_revisited] 

**[http://en.wikipedia.org/w/wiki.phtml?title=Special:Whatlinkshere&target=MediaWiki:Larry Pages which link to {msg:larry}] (Very incomplete -- many partially-wikified articles which still contain verbatim portions of his text have the message removed.)
**[http://www.google.com/search?q=%22larry%27s+text%22&btnG=Google+Search&domains=http%3A%2F%2Fen.wikipedia.org&ie=iso-8859-1&oe=iso-8859-1&sitesearch=http%3A%2F%2Fen.wikipedia.org Google search for pages containing "larry's text"] (likely to to be out of date)

====Larry's Text part 2: wikisourcify====
Make the original versions of Larry's text available from [[Wikisource]], so they can be referred to and acknowledged properly.

====Article Series====

We are working on a number of article series. These are series of philosophical articles that are bound by a common theme or philosophical subject, and will be linked by navigational boxes similar to those on [[Wikipedia:MediaWiki custom elements]]. Connecting articles in this way will create more cohesiveness throughout the philosophy articles, and will allow us to locate which articles deserve the most attention, and work on them one by one.

For more information, or to help out, see [[Wikipedia:WikiProject Philosophy/Article Series|/Article Series]].

Poor Yorick's NB: The Article Series is mostly outdated now, in favour for Wikipedia's Categories.