Editing Prior Analytics

{{Short description|Work of Aristotle pertaining to logic}}
{{italic title}}
[[File:Firenze, porfirio, isagoge, e miscellanea di aristotele, 1290 ca. 01, pluteo 11 sin 1. f. 138r.jpg|thumb|300px|Aristotle ''Prior Analytics'' in Latin, 1290 circa, [[Biblioteca Medicea Laurenziana]], Florence]]
The '''''Prior Analytics''''' ({{langx|grc|Ἀναλυτικὰ Πρότερα}}; {{langx|la|Analytica Priora}}) is a work by [[Aristotle]] on [[deductive reasoning|reasoning]], known as [[syllogistic]], composed around 350 BCE.<ref>[http://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/prior.html Aristotle's ''Prior Analytic''s Classical archive, Massachusetts Institute of Technology]</ref> Being one of the six extant Aristotelian writings on logic and scientific method, it is part of what later [[Peripatetics]] called the ''[[Organon]]''. 

The term ''analytics'' comes from the Greek words ''analytos'' (ἀναλυτός, 'solvable') and ''analyo'' (ἀναλύω, 'to solve', literally 'to loose'). However, in Aristotle's corpus, there are distinguishable differences in the meaning of ἀναλύω and its cognates. There is also the possibility that Aristotle may have borrowed his use of the word "analysis" from his teacher [[Plato]]. On the other hand, the meaning that best fits the ''Analytics'' is one derived from the study of Geometry and this meaning is very close to what Aristotle calls ''[[episteme]]'' (επιστήμη), knowing the reasoned facts. Therefore, Analysis is the process of finding the reasoned facts.<ref>{{cite book |author=Patrick Hugh Byrne |title=Analysis and Science in Aristotle |page=3 |quote=... while "decompose" - the most prevalent connotation of "analyze" in the modern period&nbsp;— is among Aristotle's meanings, it is neither the sole meaning nor the principal meaning nor the meaning which best characterizes the work, Analytics. |year=1997 |publisher=SUNY Press |isbn=0-7914-3321-8}}</ref>

In the ''Analytics'' then, ''Prior Analytics'' is the first theoretical part dealing with the science of deduction and the ''[[Posterior Analytics]]'' is the second demonstratively practical part. ''Prior Analytics'' gives an account of deductions in general narrowed down to three basic [[syllogism]]s while ''Posterior Analytics'' deals with demonstration.<ref>{{cite book |last=Smith |first=Robin |title=Aristotle: Prior Analytics |pages=XIII-XVI |year=1989 |publisher=Hackett Publishing Co. |isbn=0-87220-064-7 |quote=... This leads him to what I would regard as the most original and brilliant insight in the entire work.}}</ref>

==Legacy==
[[File:Aristotle Opera Logica.jpg|thumb|236px<!--(approx Sidebar/Infobox)-->|Page from a 13th/14th-century Latin transcript of Aristotle's ''Opera Logica''.]]
Aristotle's ''Prior Analytics'' represents the first time in history when Logic is scientifically investigated. On those grounds alone, Aristotle could be considered the Father of Logic for as he himself says in ''[[Sophistical Refutations]]'', "When it comes to this subject, it is not the case that part had been worked out before in advance and part had not; instead, nothing existed at all."<ref>{{cite book |editor=Jonathan Barnes |title=The Cambridge Companion to Aristotle |page=27 |year=1995 |publisher=Cambridge University Press |isbn=0-521-42294-9 |quote=History's first logic has also been the most influential...}}</ref>

=== Ancient commentaries ===
In the third century AD, [[Alexander of Aphrodisias]]'s commentary on the ''Prior Analytics'' is the oldest extant and one of the best of the ancient tradition and is available in the English language.<ref>{{cite book |last=Striker |first=Gisela |title=Aristotle: ''Prior Analytics'', Book 1 |page=xx |year=2009 |publisher=Oxford University Press |isbn=978-0-19-925041-7}}</ref>

In the sixth century, [[Boethius]] composed the first known Latin translation of the ''Prior Analytics'', however, this translation has not survived, and the ''Prior Analytics'' may have been unavailable in [[Western Europe]] until the eleventh century, when it was quoted from by [[Bernard of Utrecht]].<ref>{{cite conference |url=http://www.illinoismedieval.org/ems/VOL4/huygens.html |title=Looking for Manuscripts... and Then? |author=R. B. C. Huygens |conference=Essays in Medieval Studies: Proceedings of the Illinois Medieval Association |volume=4 |year=1997 |publisher=Illinois Medieval Association}}</ref> 

The so-called ''Anonymus Aurelianensis III'' from the second half of the twelfth century is the first extant Latin commentary, or rather fragment of a commentary.<ref>{{cite book |last=Ebbesen |first=Sten |title=Greek-Latin philosophical interaction |pages=171–173 |quote=Authoritative texts beget commentaries. Boethus of Sidon (late first century BC?) may have been one of the first to write one on ''Prior Analytics''. |year=2008 |publisher=Ashgate Publishing Ltd. |isbn=978-0-7546-5837-5}}</ref>

=== Modern reception ===
Modern work on Aristotle's logic builds on the tradition started in 1951 with the establishment by [[Jan Łukasiewicz]] of a revolutionary paradigm. His approach was replaced in the early 1970s in a series of papers by [[John Corcoran (logician)|John Corcoran]] and [[Timothy Smiley]]<ref>Egli, Urs. 1986. "Stoic Syntax and Semantics." Pp. 135–47 in ''Les Stoiciens et leur logique'' (1st ed.), edited by J. Brunschwig. Paris: Vrin. (2nd ed., 2006, pp. 131–48.) "We should not let modern standard systems force us to distort our interpretations of the ancient doctrines. A good example is the Corcoran-Smiley interpretation of Aristotelian categorical syllogistic which permits us to translate the actual details of the Aristotelian exposition almost sentencewise into modern notation (Corcoran 1974a; Smiley 1973). Lukasiewicz (1957) once thought that most of Aristotle's more specific methods were inadequate because they could not be formulated in the modern systems then known. He arrived at such a formulation only by distorting Aristotle's thought to a certain degree. In this respect Corcoran's interpretation is far superior in that it is very near to the texts while being fully correct from the point of view of modern logic."</ref>—which inform modern translations of ''Prior Analytics'' by Robin Smith in 1989 and [[Gisela Striker]] in 2009.<ref>*Review of "Aristotle, Prior Analytics: Book I, Gisela Striker (translation and commentary), Oxford UP, 2009, 268pp., $39.95 (pbk), {{ISBN|978-0-19-925041-7}}." in the ''Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews'', [http://ndpr.nd.edu/review.cfm?id=18787 2010.02.02].</ref>

A problem in meaning arises in the study of ''Prior Analytics'' for the word ''syllogism'' as used by Aristotle in general does not carry the same narrow connotation as it does at present; Aristotle defines this term in a way that would apply to a wide range of [[valid argument]]s. In the ''Prior Analytics'', Aristotle defines syllogism as "a deduction in a discourse in which, certain things being supposed, something different from the things supposed results of necessity because these things are so." In modern times, this definition has led to a debate as to how the word "syllogism" should be interpreted. At present, ''syllogism'' is used exclusively as the method used to reach a conclusion closely resembling the "syllogisms" of traditional logic texts: two premises followed by a conclusion each of which is a categorical sentence containing all together three terms, two extremes which appear in the conclusion and one middle term which appears in both premises but not in the conclusion. Some scholars prefer to use the word "deduction" instead as the meaning given by Aristotle to the Greek word ''syllogismos'' (συλλογισμός). Scholars [[Jan Lukasiewicz]], [[Józef Maria Bocheński]] and Günther Patzig have sided with the [[Antecedent (logic)|Protasis]]-[[Consequent|Apodosis]] [[dichotomy]] while [[John Corcoran (logician)|John Corcoran]] prefers to consider a syllogism as simply a deduction.<ref>{{cite book |last=Lagerlund |first=Henrik |title=Modal Syllogistics in the Middle Ages |pages=3–4 |quote=In the ''Prior Analytics'' Aristotle presents the first logical system, i.e., the theory of the syllogisms. |year=2000 |publisher=BRILL |isbn=978-90-04-11626-9}}</ref>

== See also ==
* [[Law of identity]]
* ''[[Reductio ad absurdum]]''

== Notes ==
{{reflist}}

== Bibliography ==
'''Greek text'''
* Aristotle. ''Analytica Priora et Posteriora''. Ed. Ross and Minio-Paluello. Oxford University Press, 1981. ISBN 9780198145622.
* Aristotle. ''Categories; On Interpretation; Prior Analytics''. Greek text with translation by H. P. Cooke, Hugh Tredennick. Loeb Classical Library 325. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1938. ISBN 9780674993594.
'''Translations'''
* Aristotle, ''Prior Analytics'', translated by Robin Smith, Indianapolis: Hackett, 1989.
* Aristotle, ''Prior Analytics Book I'', translated by Gisela Striker, Oxford: Clarendon Press 2009.
'''Studies'''
* Corcoran, John (ed.), 1974. ''Ancient Logic and its Modern Interpretations.'', Dordrecht: Reidel.
* Corcoran, John, 1974a. "Aristotle's Natural Deduction System". ''Ancient Logic and its Modern Interpretations'', pp. 85-131.
* Lukasiewicz, Jan, 1957. ''Aristotle's Syllogistic from the Standpoint of Modern Formal Logic.'' 2nd edition. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
* Smiley, Timothy. 1973. "What Is a Syllogism?", ''Journal of Philosophical Logic'', 2, pp.136-154.

== External links ==
{{commonscat}}
{{wikisource|Prior Analytics}}

* The text of the ''Prior Analytics'' is available [http://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/prior.html from the MIT classics archive].
*[https://web.archive.org/web/20040405084245/http://etext.library.adelaide.edu.au/a/a8pra/ ''Prior Analytics''], trans. by A. J. Jenkinson
* {{Librivox book|title=Prior Analytics|author=Aristotle}}
*[https://archive.org/details/prioranalytics Prior Analytics - Uncompressed Audiobook]
* [https://web.archive.org/web/20170204235013/http://www.iep.utm.edu/aris-log/ Aristotle: Logic] entry by Louis Groarke in the [[Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy]]
* {{cite SEP |url-id=aristotle-logic |title=Aristotle's Logic |last=Smith |first=Robin}}
* [http://www.ontology.co/aristotle-syllogism-categorical.htm Aristotle's Prior Analytics: the Theory of Categorical Syllogism] an annotated bibliography on Aristotle's syllogistic
{{Aristotelianism}}
{{Authority control}}
[[Category:Works by Aristotle]]
[[Category:Term logic]]
[[Category:Ancient Greek logic]]
[[Category:History of logic]]
[[Category:Logic literature]]
[[Category:Syllogism]]