Editing Scop

{{Short description|Poet as represented in Old English poetry}}
[[File:A minstrel sings of famous deeds by J. R. Skelton c 1910.jpg|thumb|[[Old English literature#Poetry|Old English poetry]] such as ''[[Beowulf]]'' was composed for performance; it is widely supposed that this meant it was chanted by a scop to musical accompaniment. Illustration by [[Joseph Ratcliffe Skelton]], c. 1910]]
{{other uses}}

A '''{{lang|ags|scop}}''' ({{IPAc-en|ʃ|ɒ|p}}<ref name="Bahn">{{Cite book |title=A History of Oral Interpretation |last1=Bahn |first1=Eugene |last2=Bahn |first2=Margaret |publisher=Burgess Publishing |year=1970 |location=Minneapolis |pages=56}}</ref> or {{IPAc-en|s|k|ɒ|p}}<ref>{{cite web | title=Pronunciation: /ʃɒp/ /skɒp/ | website=oed.com | date=2020-12-10 | url=http://oed.com/view/Entry/172966?redirectedFrom=scop# | access-date=2020-12-31}}</ref>) was a poet as represented in [[Old English literature#Poetry|Old English poetry]]. The scop is the Old English counterpart of the [[Old Norse]] ''{{lang|non|[[skald]]}}'', with the important difference that "skald" was applied to historical persons, and scop is used, for the most part, to designate oral poets ''within'' Old English literature. Very little is known about scops, and their historical existence is questioned by some scholars.

== Functions ==

The scop, like the similar [[gleeman]], was a reciter of poetry. The scop, however, was typically attached to a court on a relatively permanent basis. There, he most likely received rich gifts for his performances. The performances often featured the recitation of recognisable texts such as the "old pagan legends of the Germanic tribes."<ref name="Bahn" /> However, the scop's duties also included ''composing'' his own poetry in different situations, the eulogizing of his master. While some scops moved from court to court, they were (generally speaking) less nomadic than the gleemen and had positions of greater security.<ref name="Bahn"/>

== Etymology ==

Old English {{lang|ags|scop}} and its cognate [[Old High German]] {{lang|goh|scoph, scopf, scof}} (glossing {{lang|la|poeta}} and {{lang|la|[[vates]]}}; also {{lang|la|poema}}) may be related to the verb {{lang|ang|scapan}} "to create, form" (Old Norse {{lang|non|skapa}}, Old High German {{lang|goh|scaffan}}; [[Modern English]] {{wikt-lang|en|shape}}), from Proto-Germanic {{lang|gem-x-proto|skapiz}} "form, order" (from a Proto-Indo-European {{lang|ine-x-proto|(s)kep-}} "cut, hack"), perfectly parallel to the notion of craftsmanship expressed by the [[Ancient Greek|Greek]] {{lang|grc-Latn|poetēs}} itself;<ref>suggested e.g. by Alexander 1966</ref> Gerhard Köbler suggests that the West Germanic word may indeed be a [[calque]] of Latin {{lang|la|poeta}}.<ref>{{cite book| last = Köbler| first = Gerhard| title = Wörterbuch des althochdeutschen Sprachschatzes| publisher = Schöningh| edition = 4| date = 1993| location = Paderborn| page =220| isbn = 3-506-74661-8}}</ref>

== ''Scop'', {{lang|goh|scopf}}, and relationship to ''scold''==
While {{lang|non|skop}} became English {{wikt-lang|en|scoff}}, the Old Norse {{lang|non|skald}} lives on in a [[Modern English]] word of a similarly deprecating meaning, {{wikt-lang|en|scold}}.<ref>{{Cite web |url=https://www.etymonline.com/word/scold |title=scold |website=Online Etymology Dictionary }}</ref> There is a homonymous Old High German {{lang|goh|scopf}} meaning "abuse, derision" ([[Old Norse]] {{lang|non|skop}}, meaning "mocking, scolding", whence ''scoff''), a third meaning "tuft of hair", and yet another meaning "barn" (cognate to English ''shop''). They may all derive from a Proto-Germanic {{lang|gem-x-proto|skupa}}.

The association with jesting or mocking was, however, strong in Old High German. There was a {{lang|goh|skopfari}} glossing both {{lang|la|poeta}} and {{lang|la|comicus}} and a {{lang|goh|skopfliod}} glossing {{lang|la|canticum rusticum et ineptum}} and {{lang|la|psalmus plebeius}}. {{lang|goh|Skopfsang}}, on the other hand, is of a higher register, glossing {{lang|la|poema, poesis, tragoedia}}. The words involving jesting are derived from another root, Proto-Indo-European {{lang|ine-x-proto|skeub-}} "push, thrust", related to English ''shove, shuffle'', and the [[Oxford English Dictionary]] favours association of ''{{lang|ags|scop}}'' with that root. The question cannot be decided formally since the Proto-Germanic forms coincided in [[Indo-European ablaut|zero grade]], and by the time of the surviving sources (from the late 8th century), the association with both roots may have influenced the word for several centuries.

== Literary fiction or reality==
{{see|Translating Beowulf}}

The scholar of literature [[Seth Lerer]] suggests that "What we have come to think of as the inherently 'oral' quality of Old English Poetry{{nbsp}}... [may] be a literary fiction of its own."<ref>{{Cite book |title=Literacy and Power in Anglo-Saxon Literature |last=Lerer |first=Seth |publisher=University of Nebraska Press |year=1991 |location=Lincoln, Nebraska}}</ref> Scholars of Early English have different opinions on whether the Anglo-Saxon oral poet ever really existed. Much of the poetry that survives does have an oral quality to it, but some scholars argue that it is a trait carried over from an earlier Germanic period. If, as some critics believe, the idea of the Anglo-Saxon oral poet is based on the Old Norse [[Skald]], it can be seen as a link to the heroic past of the Germanic peoples. There is no proof that the "scop" existed, and it could be a literary device allowing poetry to give an impression of orality and performance. This poet figure recurs throughout the literature of the period, whether real or not. Examples are the poems [[Widsith]] and [[Deor]], in the [[Exeter Book]], which draw on the idea of the mead-hall poet of the heroic age and, along with the anonymous heroic poem [[Beowulf]] express some of the strongest poetic connections to oral culture in the literature of the period.{{cn|date=March 2021}}

The scholar and translator of Old English poetry [[Michael J. Alexander|Michael Alexander]], introducing his 1966 book of ''The Earliest English Poems'', treats the scop as a reality within an oral tradition. He writes that since all the material is traditional, the oral poet achieves mastery of [[alliterative verse]] when the use of descriptive half-line formulae has become "instinctive"; at that point he can compose "with and through the form rather than simply ''in'' it". At that point, in Alexander's view, the scop "becomes invisible, and metre becomes rhythm".<ref name="Alexander 1966">{{cite book | last=Alexander |first=Michael | title=The Earliest English Poems | url=https://archive.org/details/earliestenglishp00vari | url-access=registration | publisher=Penguin | year=1966 |pages=15, 19–20|isbn=9780140441727 }}</ref>

The nature of the scop in ''Beowulf'' is addressed by another scholar-translator, [[Hugh Magennis (scholar)|Hugh Magennis]], in his book ''Translating Beowulf''. He discusses the poem's lines 867–874, which describe, in his prose gloss, "a man{{nbsp}}... mindful of songs, who remembered a multitude of stories from the whole range of ancient traditions, found new words, properly bound together".<ref name="Magennis 2011">{{cite book |last=Magennis |first=Hugh |author-link=Hugh Magennis (scholar) |title=Translating Beowulf : modern versions in English verse |publisher=[[D.S. Brewer]] |publication-place=Cambridge Rochester, New York |year=2011 |isbn=978-1-84384-394-8 |oclc=883647402 |pages=30–21 "Oral and aural"}}</ref> He notes that this offers "an image of the poetic tradition in which ''Beowulf'' participates", an oral culture: but that "in fact this narrator and this audience are [in this instance] a fiction", because when the ''Beowulf'' text is read out, the narrator is absent. So, while the poem feels like a scop's "oral utterance .. using the traditional medium of heroic poetry", it is actually "a literate work, which offers a meditation on its [centuries old] heroic world rather than itself coming directly from such a world".<ref name="Magennis 2011"/>

== Further reading ==
* Frank, Roberta. "The Search for the Anglo-Saxon Oral Poet". ''Bulletin of the John Rylands University of Manchester'', 1993. 75:11-36.
* [[John D. Niles|Niles, John D.]] "The Myth of the Anglo-Saxon Poet." ''Western Folklore'' 62.1/2(2003): 7-61.
* O'Brien O'Keeffe, Katherine. ''Visible Song: Transitional Literacy in Old English Verse''. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990. 
* [[Carol Braun Pasternack|Pasternack, Carol Braun]].  ''The Textuality of Old English Poetry.'' Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995.
* Bahn, Eugene, and Margaret L. Bahn. "Medieval Period." ''A History of Oral Interpretation''. Minneapolis: Burgess Pub., 1970. 49-83.
* Anderson, Lewis Flint: ''The Anglo-Saxon scop'', Toronto : Univ. Library, 1903, Originally presented as the author's thesis (M.A.-- University of Toronto), 1902

==See also==

* [[Grendel (novel)|Grendel]] novel
* [[Sumbel]]
* [[Bard]]
* [[Bragi]]
* [[Makar]]

==References==
{{reflist}}

{{wiktionary|scop}}
{{Old English poetry|state=autocollapse}}

[[Category:Anglo-Saxon paganism]]
[[Category:Anglo-Saxon society]]
[[Category:Old English poetry]]
[[Category:Anglo-Saxon poets| ]]
[[Category:Poets]]
[[Category:Entertainment occupations]]
[[Category:Medieval occupations]]